Seasonal traffic spikes every fall, then leaves without asking for a quote. Here is how to build one insurance landing page that captures it, and what to fix before October 15.
You run a small independent agency. Every October your phone gets busier, your ad spend goes up, and your website traffic climbs. Then January arrives and you look at the numbers: plenty of visits, not many quote requests. The traffic showed up. It just didn't do anything.
Most of the time the campaign wasn't the problem. The page the campaign pointed at was. A homepage is built to serve everyone who lands on it, which means it is built for nobody in particular. A person who clicked an open enrollment ad has one question in mind, and your homepage answers eleven other questions first.
An insurance landing page is a standalone page built for one campaign, one audience, and one action, with the site navigation removed so the only meaningful next step is the one you want. It is not a service page and it is not your homepage. It exists for a season or a campaign, and it can be retired or rebuilt the following year.
The distinction matters because the two page types have different jobs. A service page has to rank and inform. A landing page has to convert a visitor who arrived with intent, and every element on it either supports that or gets cut.
One caution before you build: keep the page focused on getting a conversation started, not on plan specifics. Nothing on the page should state coverage details, pricing, or who qualifies for what. The job of the page is to earn a call.
Open the page you plan to send this season's traffic to and answer these honestly:
If you count more than five form fields or more than two competing links, you have found this week's project. For a broader look at the whole site rather than one page, our guide to insurance agency website design covers the structural side.
Element | Homepage | Open enrollment landing page
Audience | Everyone | One segment, named in the headline
Navigation | Full menu | Removed
Number of offers | Several | One
Form length | Often 6+ fields | 3 to 4 fields
Primary job | Explain the agency | Start one conversation
Lifespan | Permanent | Seasonal, rebuilt each year
Success metric | Time on site, bounce | Quote requests
A landing page is one piece of a season that starts before the season does. If you are building the rest of the plan now, our Q4 insurance agency marketing plan walks through the sequence. And because more prospects now start with an AI assistant instead of a search box, it is worth knowing whether AI will recommend your agency when someone asks for a local agent.
Seasonal traffic is the easy part. Almost every agency gets some. The agencies that grow during enrollment season are the ones whose traffic lands on a page built to do one job. Build it in September, keep the form short, remove the exits, and let October be about conversations instead of construction.
Want a second set of eyes before the season starts? Get a free website review and we will tell you what your current page is costing you. Book a free consultation below.
A prospect may be asking ChatGPT for an insurance agency right now. We'll show you what it says about you — and who it's recommending instead.
No cost, no obligation · Delivered in 3 business days · Prepared by Lee
We'll check what ChatGPT, Google AI, Perplexity, and Gemini say about you — and who they're recommending instead. Free, and yours in 3 business days.
One per campaign and audience. If you run separate campaigns for Medicare-eligible prospects and for Marketplace shoppers, build two. Don't try to serve both from a single page; the headline can only speak to one of them.
Yes, on your own domain, as a page with the navigation hidden. Keeping it on your domain means the traffic and any links it earns benefit your site rather than a third-party tool.
It varies widely by traffic source and offer, so treat published benchmarks as loose context rather than a target. The useful comparison is your own page against itself: measure what it does this year, change one thing, and measure again.
It still helps. Any traffic you point at it from email, social posts, your Google Business Profile, or a printed flyer converts better on a focused page than on a homepage.
Before the traffic arrives. For a mid-October start, have the page built and tested in September so you are checking analytics in October instead of building a page.
Bought leads are the only asset in your agency that disappears the month you stop paying for it. Everything else in this guide, you keep.
Download Free
